Help Opening Port 8585 on new Server

[mjallow]

I have 2 servers.

Server A - 192.168.1.246

Server B - 192.168.1.243

External IP Address: 23.236.5.33

Firewall: Fortigate100D.

Attempting to Open: Port 8585

I have the same settings for Server A and Server B in fortigate100D

Under Virtual IPS For Server B:

Interface: Any 

External IP Address: 23.236.5.33

Mapped IP Address/Range: 192.168.1.243

Protocol: TCP

External Port Service: 86

Map to Port: 8585

We have port 85,86  open with Server A.

I used Port 88 to test with.

I was able to open Port 88 however any other port i try and open with Server A fails except for port 88.

No ports whatsoever work when I use Server B as the mapped IP range (Mapped IP range 192.168.1.243)

[Dave_Hall]

If you are trying to create port forwards to two internal servers, you need to set them up on different external ports: e.g.

config firewall vip     edit "vip-to-server1"         set extintf "wan1"         set portforward enable         set mappedip "192.168.1.246"         set extport 85-86         set mappedport 8585-8586     next     edit "vip-to-server2"         set extintf "wan1"         set portforward enable         set mappedip "192.168.1.243"         set extport 88         set mappedport 8585     next end

Then on the firewall policy, set the source address accordingly (e.g. 0/0 or all for any device connection) then set the dest address to the VIPs. Set NAT accordingly.