FortiGate
FortiGate Next Generation Firewall utilizes purpose-built security processors and threat intelligence security services from FortiGuard labs to deliver top-rated protection and high performance, including encrypted traffic.
alwis
Staff
Staff
Article Id 209842
Description This article explains about IPSec site-to-site VPN between FortiGate and Sonicwall fails with error message 'ignoring unencrypted INVALID-COOKIE'.
Scope

 FortiGate, IPSec

Solution

Topology:

FortiGate(Private IP on WAN interface) -> NAT Router(Azure) ->IPsec -> Sonicwall.

 

IPsec VPN failed to be established when Sonicwall pointed to dynamic IP [i.e FortiDDNS]. Debug output on FortiGate shows, after the second message is received by the initiator 'ignoring unencrypted INVALID-COOKIE'  and retransmit.

 

Note:

Sonicwall will not properly recognize the NAT'ed IP.

 

To address this issue, on the Sonicwall side, add the Peer ID [IPV4 Address] to FortiGate's private IP facing the NAT Router. 

 

If FortiGate is not behind NAT (i.e, FortiGate does not have a private IP), try removing the Local IKE ID and Peer IKE ID on Sonicwall:

 

Even though FortiGate is not behind NAT and is still facing the same issue, try to define a public IP address in the Sonicwall peer Ike ID.

 

Sonicwall_invalid_cookie.jpg

 

However, if the SonicWall is running firmware v5.6.2.1 or the latest version, it is mandatory to specify the Local IKE ID; otherwise, the following error will occur:

Screenshot_(1157)(1)...........png