Skip to main content
FortiAdam
New Member
September 19, 2014
Question

Fortiguard Rating Error

I' m running a 100D on 5.0.7. Lately I had a machine that was able to make a connection out to a known botnet source because a rating error had occurred. This same IP had been rated as Malicious prior to the connection and even after the connection and was blocked. I considered using the option to block a site when a rating error occurs but looking through my logs I am finding that there are numerous rating errors and I don' t want to block legitimate traffic. Does anyone have experience with Fortiguard rating errors? I have a good connection at this site and am not having any other issues with Fortiguard services that I am aware of.

    11 replies

    Dave_Hall
    New Member
    September 19, 2014

    A ratings error occurs if the Fortigate can not reach the FortiGuard service and/or the site is is not actually given a FortiGuard rating (though I think you' ll be getting an unknown rating error in that case). Keep in mind that the FortiGuard service works on mostly web traffic -- you will want to look into IPS/App control sensors to block botnet connections. See this thread for a good discussion on blocking botnet connections, at various UTM levels.

    FortiAdam
    FortiAdamAuthor
    New Member
    September 22, 2014
    Hi Dave, thanks for the reply! I think there is a pretty significant difference between an unrated website and an actual rating error. The problem I' m dealing with here pertains to actual rating errors occurring. I' m seeing this on all different kinds of sites but not on a consistent basis. I appreciate the feedback on how to block botnet connections but at this point I' m not really looking to take this conversation into that subject. I' m really just concerned with Fortiguard categories and how I can avoid getting rating errors in the future.
    Christopher_McMullan
    Staff
    Staff
    September 22, 2014
    What is the output when you run ' diag debug rating' - are there any dropped packets in the last column?
    FortiAdam
    FortiAdamAuthor
    New Member
    September 23, 2014
    Yes I have plenty of lost packets showing on almost every IP in the list. I' m going to try setting the webfilter-sdns-server-port to 8888 and see if that helps at all.
    Dave_Hall
    New Member
    September 25, 2014
    Just curious to know if you are receiving packet lost on connections going out the WAN port? Can you perform a " diag hardware deviceinfo nic <interface name>" and check for any errors reported? (Possible duplex mismatch.)
    ShrewLWD
    New Member
    September 25, 2014
    We get this pretty consistently when the ISP of one of our locations blocks or degrades DNS queries off-network, and our Fortigate is set to use Fortinet' s DNS servers. In your Fortiguard settings, do you have your webfilter option set to regular 53, or port 8888? We have found switching it to 8888 stops all of our ' Rating Error Occurs' . EDIT: Sorry, just saw your last post attempting to switch to 8888. I' m curious to see if that solves it for you.
    FortiAdam
    FortiAdamAuthor
    New Member
    September 25, 2014
    Dave: No errors on the interface. I assume that would degrade service to the point where we would have noticed it but you never know. ShrewLWD: Thanks for the edit - I have been using 8888 for a few days now. Here' s my output of " diag debug rating" for today: -=- Server List (Thu Sep 25 13:26:07 2014) -=- IP Weight RTT Flags TZ Packets Curr Lost Total Lost 69.195.205.101 10 44 -5 292603 0 922 66.117.56.42 10 78 -5 88467 0 328 64.26.151.36 10 93 -5 35453 0 104 64.26.151.37 10 93 -5 35320 0 103 209.222.147.43 10 57 -5 73235 0 276 209.222.147.36 10 130 -5 83185 0 232 64.26.151.35 10 91 -5 35765 0 101 66.117.56.37 10 57 -5 89184 0 307 69.195.205.102 10 45 -5 357885 0 6916 96.45.33.65 20 71 -8 38471 0 92 96.45.33.64 20 71 -8 36537 0 94 208.91.112.200 20 111 -8 35421 0 222 208.91.112.196 20 115 DI -8 36395 0 1079 208.91.112.198 20 114 D -8 36807 0 1574 80.85.69.40 60 148 0 35335 0 132 80.85.69.41 60 148 0 35333 0 130 80.85.69.37 60 148 0 35341 0 139 80.85.69.38 60 148 0 35357 0 156 62.209.40.72 70 163 1 35390 0 188 62.209.40.73 70 163 1 35424 0 224 62.209.40.74 70 164 1 35478 0 279 121.111.236.179 150 197 9 35463 0 276 121.111.236.180 150 195 9 35358 0 153 69.195.205.103 45 44 F -5 39178 38994 38995
    FortiAdam
    FortiAdamAuthor
    New Member
    September 25, 2014
    Well a closer look at my logs showed that changing the port to 8888 for fortiguard lookups seems to have cleared up my issue afterall. Thanks for the suggestions everyone!
    DataPartnerInc
    New Member
    October 25, 2014

    It is may also be possible to use Security Profiles>Web Filter>Rating Overrides and set up a Custom Category to assign the sites you want to allow in spite of rating error or being "Unrated".

    sotir1984
    New Member
    May 19, 2017

    Is "rating error occurred" written anywhere in the logs

     

    Sotir

    mgoswami
    Staff
    Staff
    October 10, 2022

    Rating error  may be caused by:

    - An issue about the rating of the FortiGuard Web Filtering feature.
    - The expiration of the Web Filtering license.

     

    https://community.fortinet.com/t5/FortiGate/Technical-Tip-Web-Page-Blocked-An-error-occurred-while-trying-to/ta-p/191998

    Thought Leadership. Security Summit. Thursday, November 12th, PGA National Resort, Palm Beach Gardens, FL.
    Thought Leadership. Security Summit. Thursday, October 8th. Disney's Grand Californian Hotel & SPA, Anaheim, CA.
    Security Operations Summit: Modernize SecOps. Operate AI-Native.AMER: November 4 | 9:00 AM PST. India and SAARC: November 5 | 10:00 AM IST. EMEA: November 5 | 10:30 AM CET. APAC: November 5 | 11:00 AM SGT